A programmatic agency RFP should make every bidder answer the same operational questions. That is the only reliable way to compare platform access, media costs, data rights, service coverage and exit terms without getting lost in pitch language.
This guide gives you a 25-question programmatic agency RFP template, a response format and a weighted scoring model. Use it for a new agency search, a trading desk review or a managed-service renewal.
Quick answer: A strong programmatic agency RFP asks who owns the DSP relationship, what the buyer can access, how every fee is disclosed, which data can be exported, who operates the account, how incidents are handled and what happens at exit. Require evidence for each answer. Score access, fees, data, governance and support separately instead of choosing the best presentation.
What is a programmatic agency RFP?
A programmatic agency request for proposal is a structured brief used to compare agencies, trading desks and platform partners against the same requirements. It defines the work, asks specific commercial and technical questions, requests evidence and gives evaluators a consistent scoring method.
An RFP is useful when the decision affects more than media performance. The selected partner may control DSP access, audiences, conversion tags, supply paths, reporting, billing and historical data. Those operating choices can be difficult to change after launch.
If you are still deciding which type of partner belongs on the shortlist, start with our guide to programmatic agencies vs. media buying agencies. If you already have candidates, use the questions below to compare how they will actually run the work.
What to include before the 25 questions
Give every bidder enough context to propose the same job. Include:
Business objective and primary campaign outcomes
Markets, languages and regulated categories
Estimated annual media spend and expected flight dates
Required channels, including display, online video, CTV, audio, native, in-app or digital out-of-home
Current DSPs, ad servers, analytics, verification and consent systems
First-party data sources and activation constraints
Internal team roles and the work that must stay in-house
Reporting cadence, attribution limits and decision deadlines
Procurement, legal, privacy and information-security requirements
Target launch date and any transition from an incumbent partner
Ask candidates to use the same response format. Set a page limit, require links to supporting evidence and separate mandatory requirements from preferences. A clear response rule saves more evaluation time than another pitch meeting.
How to score a programmatic agency RFP
Score each answer from 1 to 5, then apply category weights:
Platform access and account control: 25%
Fees and commercial terms: 20%
Data, measurement and reporting: 20%
Inventory quality, privacy and governance: 15%
Team, support and exit: 20%
Use a 1 for an unsupported claim, 3 for a complete answer with limited evidence and 5 for a complete answer backed by a sample, contract language or live demonstration. Do not average away a critical failure. Undisclosed media markups, unclear data rights, missing privacy controls or no credible exit path should be pass-fail gates.
Platform access and account control
1. Which DSPs will you use, and why does each platform fit this brief?
Require the agency to connect every recommended DSP to inventory, data, market or measurement requirements. A platform list is not a strategy. The answer should also state which capabilities depend on another vendor or reseller.
2. Do you hold the DSP seat directly or buy through another company?
Identify every commercial layer between your company and the buying platform. A reseller arrangement can work, but it changes support, billing, data access and escalation. The RFP response should name each party that can access the account or charge against media.
3. What account structure will you create, and who will own or administer it?
Ask where the advertiser, campaigns, pixels, audiences, creative assets and deals will sit. Define who can create users, change permissions and approve integrations. Ownership language should match the actual platform structure.
4. Which user roles and platform views will our team receive?
"Dashboard access" is too vague. Ask whether your team can inspect campaign settings, bids, budgets, supply sources, change history, audiences, conversion definitions and raw reports. Specify what can be viewed, edited and exported.
5. What can we export, transfer or rebuild if the relationship ends?
Portability varies by platform and asset type. Ask separately about reporting history, pixels, audiences, creatives, private marketplace deals, blocklists, inclusion lists and campaign structures. Do not accept a general promise that "the client owns the data."
Fees and commercial terms
6. Show the complete cost model using our expected budget.
Ask for a worked example, not a rate card. The example should calculate costs at the same budget and channel mix for every bidder. It should show what reaches media and what pays for technology, data and service.
7. Which costs are charged as a percentage, CPM, fixed fee or markup?
Programmatic costs can appear in several places. Ask the agency to separate media, DSP technology, data, verification, ad serving, creative, managed service and custom reporting. State whether taxes and currency conversion sit inside or outside the quoted amount.
8. Do you apply any undisclosed media, inventory or data markup?
Ask the question directly. An all-in CPM can hide the agency's margin and make proposals difficult to compare. If the commercial model uses a markup, the response should define where it applies and how the buyer can reconcile it.
9. What minimum spend, deposit, payment timing and cancellation terms apply?
Minimums can differ by DSP, market, inventory deal or service model. Ask what happens when spend falls below plan, a campaign pauses, an invoice is disputed or a publisher issues a credit.
10. Which work is included, and what triggers an out-of-scope charge?
Define the service boundary before the first urgent request. Ask about strategy changes, extra markets, new campaigns, custom analysis, creative resizing, tagging support, weekend launches and incident response.
Data, measurement and reporting
11. Who owns the campaign, audience, conversion and reporting data?
Ownership, access and portability are different rights. Ask the agency to define each one for platform data, first-party data, modeled audiences, conversion events and reports. The answer should also cover subcontractors and platform terms.
12. How will you activate our first-party data?
Ask which identifiers, integrations and consent signals are required. The proposal should explain onboarding, match-rate reporting, exclusions, refresh cadence, suppression and regional restrictions without promising that every record will be addressable.
13. Which conversion events and attribution rules will be used?
Require precise definitions for primary and secondary events, lookback windows, view-through treatment, deduplication and cross-device measurement. Platform-attributed conversions should not be presented as automatically incremental.
14. Which raw reports and logs can we receive?
Ask for the most granular lawful data the proposed setup supports. Useful fields may include campaign settings, spend, impressions, domains or apps, exchanges, deal IDs, creative, audience, geography and timestamps. Privacy rules and platform policies may limit user-level or log-level exports, so the agency should state those limits clearly.
15. How will reporting reconcile with our analytics and finance systems?
DSP, ad server, analytics and finance totals will not match automatically. Ask which source controls each metric, how time zones and currencies are handled, how discrepancies are investigated and when monthly numbers become final.
Inventory quality, privacy and governance
16. Which inventory routes will you use?
Ask how the plan divides spend across open auction, private marketplaces, programmatic guaranteed and direct deals. The answer should explain why each route is needed and how supply partners are selected.
17. How will you inspect supply paths and avoid unnecessary intermediaries?
Request the controls used to review sellers, reseller chains, duplicate routes and supply quality. The agency should be able to explain how it uses industry transparency files such as ads.txt, app-ads.txt and sellers.json, along with platform reporting and verification data.
18. Which brand-safety, suitability, fraud and viewability controls are included?
Ask for category-specific rules, not a generic claim of premium inventory. Define pre-bid filters, post-bid measurement, invalid-traffic treatment, app and domain controls, made-for-advertising policy and escalation thresholds.
19. How will privacy, consent and regional data requirements be handled?
The agency should identify its role, subprocessors, transfer mechanisms, retention periods and consent dependencies. Ask how campaigns change when a market, audience source or measurement method creates a new privacy requirement.
20. Who approves campaign changes, and how are changes recorded?
Define the decisions the agency can make without approval, the thresholds that require sign-off and the emergency controls for overspend, unsafe delivery or broken measurement. A change log makes the operating model auditable.
Team, support and exit
21. Who will work on the account, and how much capacity is assigned?
Meet the operators, not only the pitch team. Ask for named roles, seniority, location, working hours, backup coverage and the number of accounts each person supports. Clarify which tasks are performed by employees, affiliates or subcontractors.
22. What service levels apply to launches, routine requests and incidents?
Separate acknowledgement, diagnosis, containment, update and resolution targets. A promise to "respond quickly" is not an SLA. Define severity levels, service hours, holiday coverage and dependencies outside the agency's control.
23. What is the optimization and communication cadence?
Ask how often the team reviews pacing, bids, supply, audiences, frequency, creative and measurement. Define meeting cadence, report delivery, decision owners and the format for recommendations. The useful answer describes a repeatable operating rhythm.
24. How will onboarding and launch QA work?
Require a plan from contract signature to first impression. It should cover access, tags, audiences, creative, naming, budgets, brand safety, reporting, billing and approvals. Ask who signs the launch checklist and how failed checks are handled.
25. What happens during offboarding?
Agree the exit process before selection. Ask about notice periods, final reporting, asset exports, account access, knowledge transfer, data deletion, unpaid media, credits and post-termination support. The answer should distinguish what transfers, what can only be exported and what must be rebuilt.
How to compare the responses
Run the evaluation in 3 passes:
1. Compliance check: Remove responses that miss mandatory requirements or refuse to disclose material commercial, privacy or ownership terms.
2. Independent scoring: Ask evaluators to score responses before the pitch meeting. This reduces the effect of presentation quality on technical judgment.
3. Evidence review: Use the pitch to test unclear answers, inspect samples and meet the proposed team. Do not spend the session repeating the written response.
Shortlist 2 or 3 candidates for a final commercial comparison. Normalize their costs against the same media budget, markets and channel mix. If the operating models differ, show the internal work your team must still provide under each option.
Red flags in a programmatic agency proposal
The agency will not name the DSP seat owner or downstream buying partner.
Fees are presented only as an all-in CPM with no cost breakdown.
"Full transparency" is promised without defined reports, permissions or exports.
Data ownership is stated broadly, but asset portability is not documented.
The pitch team is named, but the operators and backup coverage are not.
Platform-attributed conversions are treated as proof of incrementality.
Privacy and brand safety are described as platform defaults.
The SLA has one response target for every severity.
The proposal has no sample invoice, report, change log or launch checklist.
Offboarding is left for contract termination.
Use the RFP before the pitch
Send the questions before scheduling presentations. Give candidates the same deadline and allow one shared clarification round. Publish every material clarification to all bidders so nobody receives a different brief.
For a large or complex account, add a paid pilot. Use one representative market or campaign to test launch QA, reporting, communication, optimization evidence and invoice reconciliation. Media performance matters, but the pilot should also show whether the operating model works under real deadlines.
If your search is specifically for an agency-to-agency fulfillment model, use our comparison of white-label programmatic partners alongside this RFP. The shortlist guide helps identify candidates. This template helps evaluate them under the same rules.
How Ad Geeks can support the process
Ad Geeks supports managed, self-service and shared programmatic delivery across enterprise DSPs. We can answer this RFP against a specific market, channel mix and operating model, or help your team turn an existing media brief into a scoreable partner evaluation.
Bring the markets, channels, budget range and the work your team wants to keep in-house.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a programmatic agency RFP be?
Keep the core brief short enough to answer clearly. A practical RFP usually includes company and campaign context, 25-30 scored questions, mandatory terms and a standard pricing sheet. Put legal and security questionnaires in separate appendices when possible.
How many programmatic agencies should receive the RFP?
Invite 3-5 qualified candidates. A larger list creates more work without improving the comparison if the operating models are not already screened. Use a request for information or short discovery call to remove obvious mismatches first.
Should pricing be scored separately?
Yes. Normalize every proposal to the same budget, channels and markets. Score transparency and total cost, not only the management-fee percentage. A low visible fee can be offset by media markups, data costs or internal work that remains with your team.
What evidence should a programmatic agency provide?
Ask for a platform-access matrix, sample invoice, report, data dictionary, team chart, SLA, launch checklist, quality report, change log and offboarding plan. Redact client names and sensitive figures where needed. The goal is to verify the operating model, not collect confidential information.
What is the difference between an RFP and a programmatic agency checklist?
A checklist helps a buyer remember evaluation criteria. An RFP adds context, mandatory requirements, a response format, evidence requests, pricing instructions and a scoring model. It produces comparable proposals instead of a collection of yes-or-no answers.
When should a company run a new agency RFP?
Run an RFP when entering a new market, changing the operating model, adding major channels, moving DSP access, facing repeated transparency or support problems, or approaching a material contract renewal. Do not wait for termination to learn which assets and data can move.
Can this template be used for a white-label programmatic partner?
Yes. Add questions about client contact, agency branding, non-solicitation, margin control and who joins client meetings. Keep the same tests for platform access, fees, data, service levels and offboarding.











